Search AILEEN
Recipes

4-Ingredient Greek Yogurt Bagels You’ll Actually Crave

By Aileen Lavin · July 19, 2024
Featured 4204

The Greek Yogurt Bagels I Always Keep in My Freezer
Gluten-free or classic, these are the bagels I crave.

You Might Also Like

chickennuggets92A77604 BE8D 49FB AAC3 4AD7F5316AACThe Best Homemade Chicken Nuggets C71FAEC8 DA60 47A9 AFBB BF2BE73E883DThe Best Baked Chicken Cutlets Recipe easyroastchickenThe Easy Roast Chicken Recipe I Make Every Week
artisansourdoughbreadrecipeThe Best Sourdough Bread Recipe I Make Every Time meatloaf recipe e1769537261421Easy Meatloaf Recipe (A Family Favorite) Air Fryer Roasted Potatoes edited e1769538030967The Best Air Fryer Potato Wedges

I grew up in Miami, where Sunday mornings meant deli runs and bagels were practically a love language. But somewhere along the way, between the post-bagel bloat and my hunt for better ingredients, I took a long break from them. Until now.

RECIPE CARD

GREEK YOGURT BAGELS, TWO WAYS

Makes: 4 bagels Time: 20–25 minutes Method: Oven or Air Fryer

Ingredients (per batch)

  • 1 cup Greek yogurt (full-fat or low-fat)
  • 1 cup organic flour or gluten-free flour blend
  • 1½ tsp baking powder
  • ½ tsp sea salt
  • Olive oil spray or 1 beaten egg (for the top)
  • Your favorite seasoning (everything spice or flaky salt)

Instructions

  1. Preheat: 375°F (oven) or 350°F (air fryer).
  2. Mix: Combine yogurt, flour, baking powder, and sea salt until dough forms. It will be sticky, that’s expected.
  3. Shape: On a lightly floured surface, divide into 4 pieces. Roll into ropes and form circles, or shape into rounds and poke a hole through the center.
  4. Top: Brush with egg wash or spray lightly with olive oil. Add seasoning.
  5. Bake:
    • Oven: 20–25 minutes on parchment, until golden.
    • Air fryer: 10–12 minutes in batches, crisp outside and fluffy inside.
  6. Slice + toast: Best toasted after baking, especially if storing or freezing.
Notes Two easy finishes: everything seasoning + a swipe of butter, or flaky salt + cream cheese.

These Greek yogurt bagels are the answer to everything I missed: warm, chewy, golden on the outside, and made without any preservatives, yeast, or drama. They take under 30 minutes and require just four ingredients, no boiling, no waiting for dough to rise. Just mix, shape, season, and bake (or air fry).

I make them two ways:
✓ One with organic all-purpose flour (sometimes einkorn)
✓ One with a clean, gluten-free flour blend

Both freeze beautifully, toast like a dream, and make weekday breakfasts feel just a little more put-together.


Yogurt Bagel Toppings

Now, let’s talk toppings. Here are our go-to’s that’ll take your bagel game to the next level:

Probiotic Cream Cheese: Slather on a generous layer for a creamy, gut-healthy twist.

Farmer Cheese: For a light, fresh, and slightly tangy option.

4-ingredient greek yogurt bagels you’ll crave

Tuna Salad: Packed with protein and flavor, this is perfect for a more substantial bite.

4-ingredient greek yogurt bagels you’ll crave
4-ingredient greek yogurt bagels you’ll crave

Why Greek Yogurt Bagels?

First off, let’s chat about why these Greek yogurt bagels are a must-make:

Simple Ingredients: We’re using minimal, clean ingredients. No need for preservatives or complicated steps.

High Protein: Thanks to Greek yogurt, these bagels are protein-packed, keeping you fuller for longer.

Versatile: Top them with whatever your heart desires – from probiotic cream cheese to a hearty tuna salad.

Air Fryer Magic: No need for boiling. Just pop them in the air fryer for that perfect crispy outside and soft, chewy inside.

These Greek yogurt bagels are everything. Plus, they fit right into a busy lifestyle – no more spending hours in the kitchen.

If you love simple recipes, you’ll also want to try my La Scala Chopped Salad or High Protein Pasta.


What to Serve Them With:

• Probiotic cream cheese
• Farmer cheese with sea salt and herbs
• Classic tuna salad
• Soft scrambled eggs + avocado
• Smoked salmon + microgreens

Why You’ll Love Them:

High in protein thanks to Greek yogurt
No yeast, no boiling, no rise time
Freezer-friendly – just toast when ready
Customizable – works with whole grain or gluten-free flour
Quick & easy – perfect for busy mornings or weekend brunch

If you’ve been looking for a cleaner take on bagels that still feels nostalgic and satisfying, this is the recipe.

Pin this for later, and tag me if you try them, We love seeing your variations.

Shop My Kitchen

These are the tools I use to make this recipe.

Nordic Ware Half Sheet Pan

Nordic Ware Half Sheet Pan

Never warps

SHOP NOW
Cuisinart Mixing Bowls Set

Cuisinart Mixing Bowls Set

Stainless steel set

SHOP NOW
Silicone Spatula Set

Silicone Spatula Set

Heat-resistant

SHOP NOW

This post may contain affiliate links.

Pin It Share Email Print

The Friday Letter

Get recipes like this in your inbox.

Simple, seasonal recipes I make every week — plus what I’m cooking, reading, and shopping.

Subscribe

You Might Also Love

If you loved this recipe, you might also love my The Only Healthy Pancake Recipe You’ll Ever Need, Mona Vand Dreamy Caesar Salad, or How To Make The Best Bone Broth Rice.

More Recipes to Try

This post may contain affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only recommend products I personally use and love.

← Previous The Easiest Healthy Girl Dinner I Make on Repeat Next → High Protein Pasta Recipe

Keep Reading

i finally got into the lost kitchen — here's how to get in and what to expect - Aileen Lavin at The Lost Kitchen in Freedom, Maine with chef Erin French after an unforgettable dining experience

I Finally Got Into The Lost Kitchen: How to Get In and What to Expect

Easy roast chicken with golden-brown crispy skin roasted over potatoes in a cast iron pan

The Easy Roast Chicken Recipe I Make Every Week

Aileen Staring into water in ogunquit maine Woman in a sun hat and floral dress watching the ocean from a beach — the butter mom aesthetic in summer

Butter Mom Aesthetic: Why It’s Trending in 2026

Gifts for teen boys collage with a Nintendo Switch 2, Abercrombie hoodie, Ridge wallet and Theragun

For the Teen Boy: Gifts He Will Actually Use

Featured 1930

Miami Yoga Studio: Sol Yoga

Breakfast at Tatte Bakery on Charles Street in Beacon Hill, Boston

Where to Eat in Boston: The Restaurants We Always Go Back To

Destinations
Themes
Shop
Community
More